You are currently viewing Delivery app commission and the cost of direct restaurant orders

Delivery app commission and the cost of direct restaurant orders

A delivery app can bring in new customers and arrange the driver. Whether that is worth the cost depends on the statement for your own store and what you would have to pay to handle the same order directly.

Read the commission on your own statement

Commission depends on your merchant agreement. An older news report on South African delivery pricing gives context, but its figures are not current quotes or a reliable average for your store. Use the rate and fee base on your own statement.

For illustration, 100 orders at R150 each generate R15,000 in food sales. At an assumed 22% commission, the fee would be R3,300. At 30%, it would be R4,500, before any other applicable charges or tax.

Higher menu prices

The Financial Mail compared in-store and delivered prices. A higher menu price is separate from the delivery or service fees the customer sees. The difference between shelf and app prices is not, by itself, the amount the platform keeps.

South Africa’s Competition Commission’s 2023 inquiry remedies required Uber Eats and Mr D to tell consumers that they charge restaurants a commission and that in-store prices may differ from app prices.

What you can do with customer details

A marketplace generally controls the customer relationship and limits how restaurants may use order details. Check the platform’s terms rather than adding customer information from an app order to your own marketing list.

You compete on someone else’s shelf

Your listing competes with others on the same screen. Include any promotion costs, advertising charges and restaurant-funded discounts when comparing the two routes.

What the apps do well

A marketplace can help people discover a restaurant and may arrange delivery. Keep it where that service is worth paying for. Use your direct channel for orders you can attract and fulfil yourself.

Add a direct ordering channel

A customer who already knows your restaurant may be happy to order directly if it is easy to find your menu and place the order.

FoodChat charges a monthly fee per store rather than commission on each order. Payfast fees still apply to online payment. If you deliver, work out your own driver and delivery costs rather than assuming the delivery charge covers them.

Use the current FoodChat pricing and your own Payfast rates to compare costs for 100 equivalent orders. The Why not the apps? page sets out the channel differences. Put delivery, packaging and any promotions on the same basis before comparing totals.

Direct orders and marketing permission

Direct orders give the store an order record and a way to ask for marketing permission. Send promotions only to customers you may contact, and honour their opt-outs.

You do not have to choose one

Keep the marketplace where it brings in customers you would not otherwise reach. Promote your direct link on your own menus, counter and website. Check platform terms before putting promotional inserts into marketplace orders.

Do the sum for your own store

Compare the commission you would avoid on orders likely to move with the direct channel’s monthly fee, payment charges, staffing and delivery costs. Leave orders that depend on marketplace discovery out of the assumed switch.

Compare collection and delivery separately

Take one busy shift from last month and split the orders into collection and delivery. For collection, note the subscription allocation, any card fee, packaging and the staff time needed at handover. For delivery, add the cost of a driver, the delivery equipment, the work of dispatching orders and an allowance for trips that do not complete. Put the delivery charge you collect against those costs rather than assuming it covers them.

Check whose promotion was funded by whom. A marketplace statement can show a discount that the platform funded, one you paid for or a shared contribution. Those amounts are not interchangeable. Put everything on the same VAT basis, then compare the cost on the same basket value. The result may favour direct collection while a marketplace still makes sense for delivery to an area you cannot cover reliably.

References

Competition Commission. Online Intermediation Platforms Market Inquiry final report and remedies.